[cfp-interest 4029] Re: C FP Paper results in the 2026/11/16 WG14 meeting

Damian McGuckin damianm at esi.com.au
Wed Nov 18 23:00:35 PST 2026


On Wed, 18 Nov 2026, Damian McGuckin wrote:

>>      Banham: The "y a quiet NaN" should be worded better. Add "is".
>

One uses the mathematical phraseoly of

 	"y a NaN"
or
 	"all x not a signaling NaN

without "is" when one is describing the domain of y.

This is the current practice in C2Y - see F.10.5.2#1/1 with compound(x,n) 
and F.10.5.6#1/1 with pown(x,n). I deliberately did not want to change the 
status quo. This also seemed to be the pedagogic norm for a broad spectrum 
of Jim Thomas, Jerome Coonen, Rajan Bhakta, and myself which covers those 
who learned their mathematics in the US, Canada and Australia. Ariel, what 
about yourself from the UK?

In the standardized syntax, the domain definition is preceded by "for".

Where one is stating that "y is a quiet NaN" in a sentence however, one 
should use "is" which I hope is done.

Note that I corrected some uses of "return" that should have been returns,
i.e. with a trailing 's'.  Typo.

I will post an update next week.

- Damian


More information about the cfp-interest mailing list